Author: Maijo Otaro Genre: Noir / Crime Suspense

Reading Maijo Otaro’s Tsuchi ka Kemuri ka Kuimono (Smoke, Soil, or Sacrifices) was a thrilling experience, the kind where you simply cannot put the book down. This is a masterful piece that prioritizes sheer narrative force over structural complexity or literary depth, successfully dragging the reader into its vortex from the very first page.

The novel’s greatest strength lies in its broken yet fascinating protagonist, Shiro. Initially, he presents as a charismatic, unconventional figure who seems genuinely "cool." However, as the story unfolds, his actions and thinking spiral into complete chaos and soon become utterly incomprehensible. The reader finds themselves constantly questioning, "What is this guy doing?" yet is simultaneously unable to look away from his uncontrollable frenzy. It is the explosive charm of this "irresistible scumbag" that powers the entire narrative.

The content stands apart from mere mystery novels driven solely by plot tricks or gratuitous violence. The dark subject matter is deftly punctuated by moments of genuine humor and playful descriptions, creating a unique rhythm and tone. Notably, the use of the regional Fukuiben dialect by the characters adds a distinct, human touch and local flavor, preventing the relentless noir progression from becoming monotonous.

This book might not appeal to readers seeking profound philosophical themes. However, if you are looking for a singular, intense reading experience defined by pure excitement and entertainment, Smoke, Soil, or Sacrifices is highly recommended. It promises a non-stop, accelerating rollercoaster ride from start to finish.